Emerald Ash Borer
Council Study Session Sept. 8, 2015
The purpose of the study session, held from 8 to 9 p.m. on Tuesday, Sept. 8, was to discuss and obtain City Council’s feedback on anticipated long term impacts of the detected local emerald ash borer (EAB) infestation, city response to date, and recommendations on next steps including, but not limited to, the development of a City of Boulder Urban Forest Strategic Plan.
More information: Sept. 8, 2015 additional study session material - Emerald Ash Borer
Emerald Ash Borer (EAB) Information and FAQs
What is Emerald Ash Borer (EAB)?
Emerald Ash Borer (EAB) is a green jewel beetle that feeds on ash tree species. The beetle originated from Asia and is thought to have been introduced to North America in the 1990's on solid wood packing material.
In the U.S., EAB is a federally quarantined, invasive tree pest responsible for the death or decline of more than 50 million ash trees to date.
As of April 2015, EAB has been found in 25 states including Colorado, Michigan, Indiana, Ohio, Illinois, Iowa, Minnesota, Kansas, Kentucky, Maryland, Massachusetts, Missouri, New York, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia, Connecticut, Georgia, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Arkansas, Louisiana, and New Jersey.
How does EAB spread?
EAB moves short distances (½ mile annually) by flying and can survive longer distances in transit on ash nursery stock, ash logs, branches and firewood. EAB can spread naturally up to 6 miles per year.
What trees are susceptible to EAB?
All sizes and even very healthy ash trees can be killed by EAB. Ash species attacked by emerald ash borer include green ( Fraxinus pennsylvanica ), white ( F. americana ), black ( F. nigra ), and blue ( F. quadrangulata ), as well as horticultural cultivars of these species. Ash trees, especially green and white ash, are popular shade trees in most Colorado communities. Ash trees are relatively fast growing and several varieties produce brilliant fall colors.
How does EAB harm trees?
The larva (the immature stage of EAB) spends its life inside ash trees, feeding on the spongy layer of tissue just beneath the bark. This feeding destroys that tissue and stops the trees' ability to move water and nutrients back and forth from the roots to the rest of the tree. The tree starves and eventually dies.
Symptoms & signs of EAB
- A general decline in the health of the ash tree
- Dead branches
- Crown thinning
- Excessive sprouting
- Serpentine “S”-shaped tunnels under the bark produced by the larvae
- “D”-shaped adult exit holes on the bark surface
- Woodpeckers often remove bark from infested trees and feed on the larvae; the damage from woodpeckers can be severe and can often be seen from the ground.
Boulder is the first location where EAB has been found in Colorado. City of Boulder forestry staff identified an infected ash tree in northeast Boulder near the intersection of 30th Street and Iris Avenue, on Sept. 23, 2013. EAB will cause a significant impact on the urban tree canopy for the Colorado Front Range.
How many ash trees are in the Boulder area?
The 2013 United States Forest Service Metro Denver Urban Forest Assessment Report estimates the Denver metro area has 1.45 million ash trees and there are 616,000 trees total in Boulder with an appraised value of $1.2 billion. An estimated 15 percent or more of all urban and community trees are ash.
There are approximately 38,000 city park and public street rights-of-way trees under the jurisdiction of Boulder Parks and Recreation Urban Forestry; approximately 6,016 are ash trees (12.6% of the public tree population). An estimated 78,000 ash are located on Boulder’s private property.
To prevent the spread within Colorado, the CDA imposed and has enforced quarantine on the movement of all ash tree products and hardwood firewood out of Boulder County. The quarantine took effect Nov. 12, 2013. After discussions with the City of Boulder, Boulder County and local trash haulers, CDA also included small portions of Jefferson and Weld counties to include two landfills within the quarantine area to facilitate movement of flood debris and EAB-infested material.
The quarantine prohibits the movement of all untreated plants and plant parts of the genus Fraxinus (all ash trees) out of the quarantined area and includes, but is not limited to:
- Logs and green lumber
- Ash nursery stock
- Chips and mulch, either composted or uncomposted
- Stumps, roots and branches
- Firewood of any non-coniferous (hardwood) species
What is the City of Boulder planning to do to address EAB in our community?
- Tree plantings
- Tree removals (as needed; only if removal criteria met, see below)
- Conservative use of pesticides
- Wood utilization
- Enforcement for dangerous trees
- Ongoing public awareness
- Continued collaboration with CU / County / State / Federal and additional partners
- Urban Forest Strategic Plan including urban tree canopy analysis and diversification of urban canopy
EAB Treatment Options - Tree Removal (City Property)
Proactive ash removal work targets trees that meet the following criteria:
- High risk ash trees;
- Ash trees in poor condition, those compromised by other insect pests or exhibiting two or more known EAB signs;
- Trees with poor placement (i.e., under power lines);
- Trees with poor structure that will mature into a higher maintenance tree; and/or
- Any topped or improperly pruned ash trees.
In 2014 and 2015, 192 declining public ash have been removed (including Pearl Street Mall removals). An additional 50 public ash are projected to be removed in winter 2015 (and replaced 2016).
Urban forestry’s long term goal is to proactively address removal/replacement of untreated public trees (~4,500) to occur over next 7-8 years.
Why do trees have to be removed now, why can’t removal wait until the tree is dead?
Ash trees become very brittle as they decline and quickly become a public safety hazard more susceptible to storm damage. In addition, a phased removal and aggressive planting schedule will allow the department to spread required staffing and financial seasonal demand over time.
EAB Treatment Options - Pesticides
All ash will eventually die without pesticide treatment. EAB populations expand exponentially as does ash tree mortality – in Midwest cities without use of pesticides all ash are dying in as short of a period of time as 10-12 years after initial introduction.
How many trees have been treated for EAB in Boulder?
A total of 199 public ash trees were treated for EAB in Boulder in 2014, and a total of 573 in 2015 (on public property).
Safe pesticides are available, when properly used. Pesticides are an important component of EAB management programs for a number of reasons as they can:
- Preserve ash trees long term;
- Reduce community-wide EAB populations and therefore slow the progression of EAB;
- Spread the tree removal and replacement costs over a longer time period;
- Lower the risk and public safety concerns associated with large numbers of dying trees; and
- Spread the loss of the urban tree canopy and the subsequent loss of the environmental and economic services provided by the urban tree canopy over a longer period of time.
Pesticide treatment goals
- Slow the spread of EAB within Boulder and to other communities
- Stage removals to spread out costs
- Maintain urban tree canopy
- Preserve significant tree canopy
Long term pesticide treatment plan
- Treat primarily with TREE-äge, some trees with TreeAzin
- Treat 25% of public ash trees on a 3 year rotation (1500 trees total; approx. 500 trees/year)
- Adjacent property owners may opt out of treatment
EAB Treatment Options - EAB Biocontrol
The USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) rears the EAB biocontrols at their Michigan facility and provides the biocontrols at no cost to cities. Local APHIS staff applied for the permits necessary to release four biocontrols in Boulder. The tiny, non-stinging parasitic wasp species (Tetrastichus planipennisi) was released in September 2014, the egg parasitoid, Oobius agrili, was released over a six week period in spring, 2015, and the two remaining species, Spathius agrili and Spathius galinae were released in August, 2015.
The release site for all four biocontrol wasp species was along Boulder Creek Path, on CU Boulder property near the CU East Campus, and was approved by APHIS through the permitting process. The biocontrol releases are a cooperative project including staff from city forestry, CU, CDA and APHIS.
In 2014 and 2015, Parks and Recreation urban forestry staff planted 968 trees including 586 in known infested areas or Parks and Recreation parks/facilities. The long term tree planting goal is to plant 500 new trees annually with a focus on long term maintenance.
In 2014, for example, the City of Boulder entered into an agreement with Boulder County to use wood chips from whole trees as a quality heating fuel. The city continues to explore safe, creative, and environmentally responsible means of handling wood debris. Use of the wood for our park furnishings and the like is also being explored.
Forestry staff has also been working collaboratively with the Colorado State Forest Service to identify markets for all urban wood, not just for ash. Potential markets include:
- Chips for biomass fueled boilers for heating facilities
- Rough cut lumber
- Hardwood flooring
- Landscape timbers
- Wood stakes
- Wood pellets
The feasibility for each option will be explored in more depth during the Urban Forest Strategic Plan process.
We will post more information about treating ash trees on private property in Boulder when the information is available.Arborist Licensing and Listings
Feedback About this Page