The purpose of this grievance procedure is to provide a way to resolve disputes and complaints concerning the interpretation or application of this Agreement. This procedure is motivated by the desire of the parties to settle disputes as promptly and as economically as possible. It assumes that there will be an earnest effort on the part of the parties to resolve disputes. It is intended to:
- Help resolve disputes and complaints in as efficient a manner as possible;
- Ensure that grievances are initiated promptly in order to avoid the accumulation of old disputes;
- Provide an opportunity for a hearing to every grievant who cannot resolve their grievance through informal discussions; and,
- Provide for formal arbitration in grievances arising out of the imposition of serious discipline that cannot be resolved by less formal methods.
In any instance where an employee believes that she or he has been underpaid pursuant to this Agreement, that employee shall, upon discovery of the error, bring it to the attention of the Chief and Deputy Chiefs. If the matter is not resolved informally and a grievance is filed to recover the underpayment, and if the employee prevails, the payment error shall be corrected on a retroactive basis for a period that extends back in time to a date that is not more than one hundred eighty (180) days before written notice of the error was provided by the employee.
In any case in which it is determined that an employee has been overpaid pursuant to this Agreement, the overpayment shall be returned to the City immediately or as soon as reasonably feasible following a discussion with City management in which issues of the employee’s personal hardship may be considered.
At any step of this grievance procedure, the Executive Board of the Bargaining Unit shall have final authority to decline representation of an employee in the grievance process if, in the judgment of the Executive Board, an employee's grievance lacks merit or justification under the terms of this Agreement or has been adjusted or settled to the satisfaction of the Executive Board.
- Once a grievance has been submitted in writing, it may not be materially changed throughout the grievance procedure.
- No grievance of a disciplinary action may be filed unless the employee who is the subject of the disciplinary action endorses and participates in the grievance.
- Only grievances settled by mutual agreement between the Bargaining Unit and the City may be cited as precedent.
- In the event a disciplinary action by the City affects more than one employee, each employee affected shall file an individual grievance. Local #900 and the City may agree in writing to combine groups of like grievances or to allow Local #900 to file a single grievance on behalf of all affected employees regarding a specific action. However, if the grievances of several employees are combined or consolidated, this shall not affect the individual treatment and consideration to be given to each employee's case.
- The grievance procedures of this Agreement shall not be applicable to grievances arising in the period between the termination of this Agreement and the effective date of its successor.
- Grievance decisions shall not be interpreted to change the meaning of the Agreement.
- Employees may be represented by a Bargaining Unit Official at any step of the grievance procedure.
- Whether or not an issue is grievable may ultimately be determined by the Article or Section of the contract specifically in question.
- The time limitations set forth in this grievance procedure may be altered by the written agreement of the parties with regard to any particular grievance.
With respect to the time limits set forth in this grievance procedure:
- "Submitted" or “Rendered” - shall mean in the event of actual hand delivery, the date when the document or notice is delivered to the office or the appropriate party, and in the event of delivery by mail, the date of the postmark appearing upon the correctly addressed envelope containing the document.
- "Receipt" - shall mean, in the event of hand delivery the date when any document or notice is actually delivered to the office of the appropriate party, and in the event of delivery by mail, three (3) days after the date appearing on the postmark on the correctly addressed envelope containing such document or notice, and in the event of e-mail, the first day the recipient is on shift following the sender sending an e-mail through the City’s e-mail system to the recipient’s City e-mail address.
- In computing any period of time prescribed or allowed by this contract, the day of the act, event, or default from which the designated period of time begins shall not be included. Days shall be counted only as whole days and time shall not be computed on an hour or minute basis.
- All time limits set forth in the grievance procedure refer to calendar days except holidays as defined in Article XXX.B. of this Agreement shall not be counted.
- All time limits set forth in the grievance procedure may be extended by mutual agreement of the parties.
- The grievance procedure shall be as follows:
Step 1: Initial Complaint and Informal Discussion
An employee who believes they have a grievance shall attempt to resolve the issue informally by meeting with their immediate supervisor, if that supervisor is involved with the grievance the employee may meet with the next supervisor up the chain of command. The meeting shall take place within fourteen (14) days of the earliest of the following: (1) the date of the occurrence of the event that gives rise to the grievance; or, (2) the date upon which the aggrieved party, based upon the exercise of reasonable diligence, first had knowledge of the event giving rise to the grievance.
The failure of a grieving employee, or of the Union on behalf of that employee, to request a meeting within the fourteen (14) day period noted above will end the grievance process.
Step 2: Written Grievance
If a grievance is not resolved in Step 1 and the employee wishes to pursue it further, the employee shall reduce the grievance to writing, and submit it to the Fire Chief or designee within fourteen (14) days of the meeting described in Step 1. The document shall set forth the issues and contentions of the aggrieved party or parties and must allege violations of this Agreement with sufficient clarity and specificity so that the other party reasonable notice of the nature of the grievance.
The grievance must be signed by a Bargaining Unit Official and must be delivered to the Fire Chief and the Human Resources Director within prescribed time limits.
The employee and the Fire Chief, or the Chief’s designated representative, shall meet within fourteen (14) days after a written notice of grievance has been received. The Fire Chief shall consider all evidence material and information presented at the meeting.
The Fire Chief, or the Chief’s designee, shall render a decision on the grievance in writing to the employee and the Local #900 Grievance Committee within fourteen (14) days following the date of the Step 2 meeting. If a decision is not rendered within this period of time, the employee shall have a right to a hearing under the provisions of Step 3 of this procedure.
By written agreement, the employee and the Fire Chief may agree to skip the Step 2 process and proceed directly to Step 3 of this grievance procedure.
Step 3: Appeal to the Human Resources Director and Subsequent Response
Appeal of the Fire Chief's decision or appeal of disciplinary action imposed by the Fire Chief may be made, in writing, to the Human Resources Director by the employee and the Bargaining Unit grievance committee within fourteen (14) days after receipt of the Fire Chief's decision.
If requested by either the Human Resources Director or the grievant, the Human Resources Director or their designee shall conduct an administrative hearing to review events and circumstances involved in the grievance. At such hearing, the Human Resources Director or their designee and/or the grievant may call and cross-examine relevant witnesses and present written or verbal information. Such hearing shall be held within fourteen (14) days of the employee's request or within fourteen (14) days of appeal of the grievance if requested by the Human Resources Director or their designee. In addition, the Human Resources Director or their designee may conduct any further investigation or hold further meetings as they believe appropriate to attempt resolution of the grievance.
The Human Resource Director or their designee will issue a written answer to the grievant within fourteen (14) days, following the date of the last Step 3 meeting. If a decision is not rendered within this period of time, the employee shall have a right to a review and decision by the City Manager orby a Deputy City Manager. Any grievance not appealed to Step 4 within fourteen (14) days of the written answer described in this Step shall be considered abandoned and subject to no further appeal.
Step 4: Arbitration
If the grievance is not satisfactorily adjusted in Step 3, either party may, with reasonable promptness, but in no event later than fourteen (14) days from the date of the receipt of the Human Resources Director's written response, request arbitration. The Executive Board of the Union shall have the exclusive right to determine whether or not the employee's grievance shall be submitted to arbitration by the Union. The parties shall immediately attempt to agree upon an impartial arbitrator.
In the event the parties are unable to reach agreement upon the selection of an arbitrator within fourteen (14) days of the written request for arbitration, the parties will request a panel of seven (7) arbitrators from the American Arbitration Association. From this panel of seven (7) names, each party shall alternately strike three (3) names, the moving party striking first (1st). The remaining arbitrator from the list shall be the impartial arbitrator.
- The following shall apply to arbitration:
- The arbitrator shall have the right to arbitrate grievances concerning the interpretation or application of this Agreement.
- The arbitrator shall have no power to add to or subtract from or modify any of the terms of this Agreement or any Agreements made supplementary hereto, nor any other matter not specifically provided for within the Agreement.
- The decision of the arbitrator shall be final and binding upon the Bargaining Unit, the City, and the employee.
- All costs of the arbitrator and the arbitration procedure shall be shared equally by both parties.
- All parties to the grievance, the City, Local #900, and any individual employee or employees shall abide by all rules and regulations of the American Arbitration Association.