View Q&A responses from the neighborhood meeting on Wednesday, Oct. 14 below.

Neighborhood Meeting Q&A Responses

The Neighborhood meeting started with a presentation by Historic Preservation staff Marcy Gerwing and Clare Brandt on the benefits and responsibilities of historic district designation and a preview of the StoryMap research.

A panel discussion moderated by Historic Boulder, Inc. Executive Director and Mapleton Hill resident Tim Plass followed. Panelists included Marcy Gerwing, Principal Historic Preservation Planner with the City of Boulder (staff), Ronnie Pelusio, former Landmarks Board member, architect and urban designer; Yoann Le Ny, former Grant Place resident and current owner of a house in the Floral Park Historic District; Steven Walsh, architect.

  • Q: How does design review work?
    Panelists: The design review process was generally described as collaborative, efficient, and more approachable than participants initially expected. Staff provide guidance, answer questions, and offer thoughtful feedback that can improve project outcomes. The process is responsive and provides opportunities for discussion, including topics such as tax credits. Although it may initially seem intimidating or bureaucratic, the panelists felt that the process often results in higher-quality designs that better meet homeowners’ needs.
    Staff: Design review is completed through a Landmark Alteration Certificate and is reviewed at various levels based on scope of work. Levels of review include: staff, Landmarks Design Review Committee (LDRC) and Landmarks Board (LB). For a complete guide and process, please visit our website at: Landmark Alteration Certificate Application and Review.

  • Q: Does designation limit what a homeowner can do with their property?
    A: Designation does not prevent change; it shapes what it looks like. For example, additions are allowed and are reviewed for compatibility with the neighborhood. While this influences what a neighborhood looks like, it does not limit improvements to individual properties. Things like use and occupancy are determined by zoning, not by historic designation.
  • Q: Do larger-scale projects encounter more issues during design review?
    Panelists: Renovations and additions can benefit from early input and increased collaboration, but do not necessarily encounter issues. One example involved proposed dormers on the street-facing side of a house. Through the review process, the applicant gained a better understanding of preservation considerations and felt the resulting design was improved.
    Staff: Staff work on a collaborative basis with all LAC applications. Project scale is typically less of an issue than having clear and accurate application materials is. When materials are accurate, review is smoother and quicker.
  • Q: What happens if a historic building is completely destroyed, e.g. a wildfire? Would it have to be reconstructed to match the historic building?
    Staff: It depends on the scale of destruction from the fire. If an entire historic district were destroyed, the designation ordinance would likely be amended or revoked. If buildings are destroyed but the neighborhood is not, the replacement buildings would go through the design review process. The design guidelines discourage building an exact replica, as it creates a false sense of history. Review of new construction in a historic district focuses mainly on preserving the character of the district, particularly its scale, form, and massing and key building elements, like window pattern and dormers.
  • Q: If a building is partially destroyed, would all features have to be precisely restored?
    Staff: The extent of the damage and the significance of the affected features would determine the appropriate treatment. The goal is to preserve historic character without requiring an exact reconstruction in every situation or creating a false sense of history. Some features may warrant repair, while others may be replaced or treated differently depending on the circumstances.
  • Q: Is modern design allowed in a historic district?
    Panelists: Modern architecture is not prohibited in historic districts. Contemporary additions and designs can be successful when they are compatible with the historic context. The present day becomes part of the history of a house and neighborhood. The question is whether a new design fits appropriately into that ongoing history.
    Staff: Modern designs have been some of the most interesting design review applications to work on. Successful ones have traditional proportions and scale and then have a play on traditional building elements.
  • Q: How does historic designation affect neighbors and the ability to increase density?
    Panelists: Historic designation adds a layer of review that may influence the size, design, and placement of proposed alterations, but it does not prohibit redevelopment or additional density. Zoning regulations remain separate from historic preservation requirements. Additions, renovations, and accessory dwelling units (ADUs) are allowed (and encouraged) when they are compatible with the historic context.

    Preservation can help maintain continuity along the streetscape and retain the qualities residents value about their neighborhood, even as individual properties change. A key consideration is ensuring that additions do not overwhelm historic buildings. A transparent, predictable, and consistent review process benefits both applicants and their neighbors.
    Staff: The Landmarks Board has approved projects that sought to increase density within historic neighborhoods. ADUs, secondary primary buildings, larger garages and more have been approved. They typically go to the full Landmarks board and sometimes require revisions to proposed designs. But once again, the review is based on the character of the proposed design and its relationship to the neighborhood.
  • Q: Is just streetscape/front façade considered in review?
    A: No. The entire property is considered, although the street-facing façade may receive greater emphasis depending on the characteristics of the district. The features that contribute to a district’s historic character vary by neighborhood. For example, alleys and outbuildings may be important in some districts but less significant in others. For Grant Place, the review would focus on the features that contribute to its historic character.
  • Q: Does design review apply to both contributing vs. non-contributing?
    A: Yes. All properties within a designated historic district are subject to review because the district’s significance depends on the character of the area as a whole. However, not every feature must be preserved. Decisions depend on the property, the feature being altered, and the surrounding context.

  • Q: Does less than 340 square feet need review?
    A: Yes. Project size determines the applicable level of review, rather than whether review is required. New, free-standing construction over 240 square feet requires review by the Landmarks Board.
  • Q: Does historic designation discourage developers from pursuing projects?
    Panelists: Historic designation may add complexity to redevelopment, particularly when working with existing buildings rather than starting with an empty lot. Retaining an existing building and incorporating it into a new design can present challenges, although these difficulties are not necessarily unique to historic districts.
    Staff: Designation is not intended to prevent redevelopment. Properties can be substantially changed, and non-contributing buildings may be eligible for demolition. Any redevelopment would have to be compatible with the neighborhood, which will, to an extent, preserve the “feeling” of the district. Larger structures that maximize allowable building envelope may not be compatible with that character due to their mass and scale.
  • Q: What is the cost of design review?
    Panelists: Design review is often incorporated into the architectural design process, and drawings prepared for review may also be used for the building permit application. However, revisions or additional presentations may require extra time and expense, depending on the project. Not every project requires an architect, and costs will vary based on the scope and complexity of the work.
    Staff: There is no application fee for a Landmark Alteration Certificate application, so the cost is in the preparation of materials, meeting time, and requested revisions. Building plans and elevations are required for Building Permit, and most applications are reviewed either by staff (no meeting) or in a 20-45 minute committee meeting. The cost of revisions depends on the scale of the requested change.